PRISONS AND TORTURE IN IRAQ

INDEX RESEARCH

by Sarah Meyer
updated 22.01.07.

There is, at present, confusion about the closure date of Abu Ghraib. The United States is uncomfortable under the global spotlight on its prisons and torture policies in Iraq. Rather than moderate their policies to accommodate democratic and legal guidelines, they are, instead, planning to move ‘detainees’¹ to newly built prisons which they hope will be less visible.

In February ’04, The International Red Cross published its (January) “Report on the Treatment by the Coalition Forces of Prisoners of War and other protected persons in Iraq.” The report drew the attention of the Coalition Forces “to a number of serious violations of International Humanitarian Law.” These violations were “documented and sometimes observed while visiting prisoners of war, civilian internees and other protected persons by the Geneva Conventions (hereafter called persons deprived of their liberty when their status is not specifically mentioned) in Iraq between March and November 2003." The report said that mistreatment allegedly took place at Abu Ghraib, Camp Cropper and ‘battle group unit stations.’ Other ‘mistreatment’ places of internment mentioned were: ‘Al-Baghdadi, Heat Base and Hubbania Camp in Ramadi governate; Tikrit holding area (former Saddam Hussein Islamic School); a former train station Al-Khaim, near the Syrian border, turned into a military base; the Ministry of Defense and Presidential Palace in Baghdad, the former mukhabarat office in Basra, as well as several Iraqi police stations in Baghdad. Many of these locations are difficult to identify based on the reported place names, which in many cases do not correspond to the place names used by the US military.”

The International Red Cross also produced a later statement in May, which was a summary of the ICRC's attempts in person and in writing from March to November 2003 to get U.S. officials to stop abuses.

The first sexual humiliation, torture and homicide photographs from Abu Ghraib, taken in 2003 were released in April 2004.²

In May ’04, Seymour Hersh published The Grey Zone in the New Yorker. “The roots of the Abu Ghraib prison scandal lie not in the criminal inclinations of a few Army reservists but in a decision, approved last year by Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld …“

On May 7th, Rumsfeld testified before the Senate Armed Services Committee. More.

On the 5th of October, The US Senate³ unanimously passed a resolution Senate Resolution 356 “Condemning the abuse of Iraqi prisoners at Abu Ghraib prison, urging a full and complete investigation to ensure justice is served, and expressing support for all Americans serving nobly in Iraq.” The Senate condemned “in the strongest possible terms the despicable acts at the Abu Ghraib prison" and urged “that all individuals responsible for such despicable acts be held accountable."

In September ’04, Lisa Croke reported that a US legal team from Michigan found evidence of abuse in 24 prisons. In addition to Abu Ghraib and Camp Cooper, they mentioned Baghdad’s al-Salihiya; Al-Dhiloeia, north of Baghdad; a US base outside Fallujah; and the US/Polish jointly run Hilla military compound. “The majority of detention centers where former inmates allege American soldiers and contractors committed acts of abuse were found in and around Baghdad, most of them buildings that had been converted into prisons. (Mustansiriya University Student Housing, on the grounds of Akai Pharmaceutical Company Compound, the Palace of Conferences, the Scania transportation depot and Baghdad’s Al-Sijood Palace)… Detention centres in Tikrit reportedly include one of Saddam Hussein’s Presidential Palaces, Uday Hussein’s former horse stables, and the US-confiscated Tikrit Elementary School.”

‘Detainee’ population grew to over 11,000, more than twice the number in October ’04. Some were being held in ‘field camps’ before being moved to Abu Ghraib.

In January ’05, Tara McKelvey told the stories of women in Iraqi prisons. Ghali Hassan has also written about Iraqi Women Under Occupation.

Baghdad Dweller wrote about a women’s detention centre at Al Kazimiyah where rape⁴ and abuse occurs. There are other women’s stories: “google” ‘torture women Iraq.’

On 10 May ’05, Bradley Graham reported in The Washington Post that the US was to expand three existing detainee facilities “and open a fourth, at a total cost of about $50m.” Camp Bucca, near Umm Qasr, he wrote, would have two extra compounds built, accommodating 7,700. Camp Bucca is known for ‘bone-crushing’ abuse. Cost: $12m.

Camp Cropper, near Baghdad airport, with 120 ‘high-value detainees’, would have extensions built to accommodate 2000 (also ‘high value’?) by the end of 2005. Cost: $30m.

A Russian military barracks near al Sulaymaniyah, the capitol of Kurdistan, has been transformed into a “Theatre Internment Facility’ (aca prison), called Fort Suse. Building started in August ’05; work was subcontracted (by Parsons ⁵?) The prison will accommodate 1,700+ prisoners. The first ‘detainees’ arrived on 24.10.05. It is alleged that the prison will be run by Iraqis, after “extensive training.” Cost: $8m.

And …

Abu Ghraib was having an extension built for 800 ‘detainees.’ Cost: less than $1m.

These plans were approved by Donald Rumsfeld.

In August ’05, Portal Iraq reported on Iraqi Infrastructure. They said that “nationwide, there are 22 prison and court projects planned, with 13 ongoing and nine complete.” Where are these prisons, then?

There was an article, ‘Sheik Beaten, Blinded, Tasered, Released Into The New Iraq’ by Aaron Glantz (09.05) in which Mr. Rolands of the Christian Peacemaker Team mentioned a new prison being built by Parsons Inc. in the north of Iraq. Mr. Rolands is quoted as saying, “In my opinion, you don't build new prisons if you plan on just handing them all over to the Iraqis," Rolands says. "You build a new prison if you plan on staying a long time and arresting many Iraqis in big house raids and big sweeps." Mr Fox of the Christian Peacemaker team was recently found, tortured and murdered. The fate of the three remaining CPT members remains precarious.

By November ‘05, Larisa Alexandrovna wrote, in Raw Story, that ‘detainee’ numbers had grown to 13,514, which was confirmed by the United Nations. Only 1,300 have been tried, of which 636 have been convicted, she said. Detainees, said Raw Story, were also kept at lesser known camps. These include Camp Ashraf, where there have been reports of ‘detainee escapes.’ Camps Al-Kazimiyah and Al-Nasiriyah are mentioned. Finally, an alleged facility on Diego Garcia in the Indian Ocean, as well as “an installation on the USS Baton” are cited.¹

The 2nd release of Abu Ghraib photographs was published on 15 February 2006. Salon published the Complete Abu Ghraib files, composed of 279 photographs and 19 videos, on 15 March 2006.

At the end of February ’06, the New York Times reported that the State Department was requesting $100m for building prisons, though “no other big building projects were in the pipeline for the department's 2006 supplemental and 2007 budget requests for Iraq, which total just over $4b. Iraq Coordinator Jeffrey said that “money would also be set aside to increase the number of prosecutors and corrections advisers (sic)."

Is this request in addition to the Pentagon $50m confirmed by Rumsfeld?

Since the Washington Post story in 05.05, the prison population has grown to 30,000. More than 15,400 were recommended for release in March ’06.

On 9 March, the US DoD American Forces Information Service, said: “News reports that the U.S. military intends to close Abu Ghraib within the next few months and to transfer its prisoners to other jails are inaccurate.”

On 13 March ‘06, Peter Pace, the Chairman of the US Joint Chiefs of Staff, said, "We do have plans to and are in the process of building other facilities to move the detainees under US control out of Abu Ghraib. The facility then will be owned and operated by the Iraqi government and that government will decide when it closes - if it closes."

On the 19th of March '06, The New York Times published 'In Secret
Unit's 'Black Room,'A Grim Portrait of U.S. Abuse,' This Black Room is near Baghdad Airport, where 'honoured' American visitors arrive, smile, and say that Iraq will have 'democracy' and 'freedom'? Are there more grim stories like this one waiting for exposure?

The American Civil Liberties Union Executive Director, Antony Romero, said, “The policies are still in place, and we haven’t held high-level officials accountable for the abuse that happened on their watch. The ACLU will press on with our lawsuit to hold Donald Rumsfeld accountable. If the American government wants to restore faith in our commitment to human rights, we must hold high-ranking officials accountable for their actions. Only then will the horrors of Abu Ghraib truly come to an end.”


REPORTS

08.02 Office of the Attorney General: Memorandum for Alberto Gonzales, Re: Standards of Conduct for Interrogation (pdf)

“On 19 January 2004, Lieutenant General (LTG) Ricardo S. Sanchez, Commander, Combined Joint Task Force Seven (CJTF-7) requested that the Commander, US Central Command, appoint an Investigating Officer (IO) in the grade of Major General (MG) or above to investigate the conduct of operations within the 800th Military Police (MP) Brigade.” TAGUBA REPORT - HEARING ARTICLE 15-6 INVESTIGATION OF THE 800th MILITARY POLICE BRIGADE

01.04.04. "Request that the findings and recommendations of the subject investigation relating to BG Janis L. Karpinski be set aside and no additional adverse action taken. The 800th Military Police (MP) Brigade (Bde) under the command of BG Karpinski successfully accomplished every mission assigned despite being under-strength and under-resourced."BG Karpinski Rebuttal to AR 15-6 Investigation of the 800s' Military Police Brigade

21.07.04. Department of the Army: The Inspector General. "This inspection report responds to the Acting Secretary of the Army's 10 February 2004 directive to conduct a functional analysis of the Army's conduct of detainee and interrogation operations to identify any capability shortfalls with respect to internment, enemy prisoner of war, detention operations, and interrogation procedures and recommend appropriate resolutions or changes if required." [PDF 2.287 Mb] Detainee Operations Inspection

23.08.04. AR 15-6 Investigation of the Abu Ghraib Prison and 205th Military Intelligence Brigade by LTG Anthony R. Jones and MG George R. Fay US Army [PDF 920 Kb]


Amnesty International

18.03.04. Iraq. One year on the human rights situation remains dire.

07.04.04. An open letter to President George W. Bush on the question of torture and cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment

27.10.04. UNITED STATES OF AMERICA Human dignity denied. Torture and accountability in the ‘war on terror.

08.01.05. Cruel. Inhuman. Degrades us all. Stop torture and ill-treatment in the ‘War on terror’

06.03.06. Beyond Abu Ghraib: detention and torture in Iraq


Human Rights Watch

05.04. Letter to President Bush

05.04. Summary of International and U.S. Law Prohibiting Torture and Other Ill-treatment of Persons in Custody

06.04. The Road to Abu Ghraib

06.04. Bush Policies Led to Abuse in Iraq

07.04. Military Investigations into Treatment of Detainees in U.S. Custody

01.05. The New Iraq

04.05. Getting Away with Torture?

09.05. Leadership Failure

24.05. New Accounts of Torture by U.S. Troops 2006 World Report

01 - 02.06. "According to the Ministry of Human Rights, as of 28 February 2006, there were total of 29,565 detainees -- 14,229 in the custody of the MNF-I; 8,391 in the custody of the Ministry of Justice; 488 juveniles under the custody of the Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs; 5,997 held by the Ministry of Interior and 460 by the Ministry of Defense ... The Human Rights Office also continues to receive regular allegations and evidence of torture in detention centres, particularly those not operated or controlled by the Ministry of Justice. UN Assistance Mission for Iraq

Also see: Greenberg, Karen. The Torture Papers: The Road to Abu Ghraib, Cambridge University Press.
McCoy, Alfred. A Question of Torture, Metropolitan Books, New York, 2006.


“We don’t do torture.” CIA Director, Porter Goss, testifying before the Senate Armed Services Committee, March ’05.

How can the United States Senate and Congress sit there doing NOTHING to prevent the disgrace of US prisons in Iraq and the subsequent torture of incarcerated detainees?'


Footnotes
[1] A prisoner has legal rights. The OED definition of ‘detainer’ has negative implications, implying unlawfulness. A ‘detainee’ has no rights, and can be imprisoned, tortured, deported and/or suffer ‘rendition’ by the US/UK.
[2] Abu Ghraib Scandal Time-Line
[3] See also Treatment of Prisoners Dossier
[4] Photographs 2004; women raped in Iraq.
[5] The press release, ‘Parsons Will Design/Build Security and Justice Facilities,’ was on 29.03.04, i.e. one month before the Abu Ghraib ’03 photographs became public. This ‘awarded’ contract was worth $900m.
[6] On 14 March ’06, the Moscow Times revived an allegation that Ukraine hosted a secret CIA prison for terrorist suspects.

Updates

Detainee Abuse and Accountability Project (DAA)
April 2006. Human Rights Watch Report. The DAA Project has to date documented at least 330 cases in which U.S. military and civilian personnel are alleged to have abused detainees, ranging from beatings and assaults, to torture, sexual abuse, and homicide. Among the cases:

At least 600 U.S. personnel are implicated (numerous cases involve more than one perpetrator). Military personnel comprise over 95 percent of those implicated (at least 570 people), and at least ten CIA or other intelligence personnel are implicated, and approximately twenty civilian contractors working for either the military or the CIA.

At least 460 detainees have been subjected to abuse, including people held in Iraq, Afghanistan, and at Guantánamo Bay.

The majority of the approximately 330 cases took place in Iraq (at least 220 cases), followed by Afghanistan (at least sixty cases), and Guantánamo Bay (at least fifty cases).

Prisons and Torture in Iraq
12.12.06. S. Meyer, Index Research. There is, at present, confusion about the closure date of Abu Ghraib. The United States is uncomfortable under the global spotlight on its prisons and torture policies in Iraq. Rather than moderate their policies to accommodate democratic and legal guidelines, they are, instead, planning to move ‘detainees’1 to newly built prisons which they hope will be less visible. Prisons, Reports.

04.09.06. ABC. “Iraq for Sale.” Documentary Slams U.S. Companies Working in Iraq.

06.09.06. CBS. The new manual, called "Human Intelligence Collector Operations," applies to all the armed services, not just the Army. It does not cover the Central Intelligence Agency, which also has come under investigation for mistreatment of prisoners in Iraq and Afghanistan and for allegedly keeping suspects in secret prisons elsewhere around the world since the Sept. 11 attacks. U.S. Army Bans Torture of Prisoners..
&
06.09.06. “an attempt to authorize the CIA to engage in the sorts of ‘enhanced’ interrogation techniques. New Bush bill would legalize torture..

20.09.06. I. Arieff, Reuters. Rights groups have alleged torture takes place in prisons run by the U.S.-led multinational force as well as by the Interior and Defense ministries and militias, it said. Torture rampant in Iraqi prisons, streets, UN says..

Torture in Iraq may be worse now than it was under Saddam Hussein, with militias, terrorist groups and government forces disregarding rules on the humane treatment of prisoners, the U.N. anti-torture chief said Thursday. The Bush administration "angrily rejected" this claim.

U.S. Army Bans Torture of Prisoners
06.09.06. CBS. The new manual, called "Human Intelligence Collector Operations," applies to all the armed services, not just the Army. It does not cover the Central Intelligence Agency, which also has come under investigation for mistreatment of prisoners in Iraq and Afghanistan and for allegedly keeping suspects in secret prisons elsewhere around the world since the Sept. 11 attacks.

Torture rampant in Iraqi prisons, streets, UN says
20.09.06. I. Arieff, Reuters. Rights groups have alleged torture takes place in prisons run by the U.S.-led multinational force as well as by the Interior and Defense ministries and militias, it said.

U.N. expert: Iraq torture may be worse
21.09.06. E. Engeler, The State. Torture in Iraq may be worse now than it was under Saddam Hussein, with militias, terrorist groups and government forces disregarding rules on the humane treatment of prisoners, the U.N. anti-torture chief said Thursday. The Bush administration
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/newspaper/0,,174-2369999,00.html">
angrily rejected
this claim.


Military Commissions Act of 2006


• Bush's Military Commissions Act and the Future of America
14.10.06. Jennifer van Bergen, Counterpunch. … “While the President has consistently insisted these laws are necessary, it is becoming increasingly clear that, in addition to a huge up-swelling of anti-American sentiment in the Middle East, the administration's approach to terrorism has led to a tremendous number of false arrests and imprisonments…”


• Amnesty International Urges the Administration: "Return to the Rule of Law"
11.09.06. Amnesty Int. Press Release.

Human Rights Denial Deserves Impeachment
11.09.06. P. Phillips, ICH. The U.S. government is actively torturing people to death. One need only read the 44 official U.S. military autopsy reports on civilian detainees from Afghanistan and Iraq in 2002 to 2004 posted on the American Civil Liberties website to see the horrendous details of deaths by "strangulation," "asphyxiation" and "blunt force injuries. The Military Commission Act retroactively approved the use of torture to the beginning of the 9/11 Wars. Congress's reaction to the ACLU report in October of 2005 was to pass legislation banning further use of the Freedom of Information Act to request documents on current military operations."

Rights groups set to file Rumsfeld war crimes lawsuit in Germany
09.11.06. The Jurist. The New York-based Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR) [advocacy website] announced [press release] Thursday that a coalition of US and international human rights groups plan to file a war crimes lawsuit against outgoing US Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld [official profile] after his resignation Wednesday. Rumsfeld enjoys statutory immunity in the United States and so CCR, the National Lawyers Guild, the International Federation of Human Rights [advocacy websites] and others will file the complaint in Germany under that country's universal jurisdiction [AI backgrounder] law. See also
Video.


• Donald Rumsfeld: The War Crimes Case
Marjorie Cohen, President of the National Lawyers Guild, The Jurist Forum.

• Along with Rumsfeld, Gonzales and Tenet, the other defendants in the case are Undersecretary of Defense for Intelligence Stephen Cambone; former assistant attorney general Jay Bybee; former deputy assisant attorney general John Yoo; General Counsel for the Department of Defense William James Haynes II; and David S. Addington, Vice President Dick Cheney's chief of staff. Senior military officers named in the filing are General Ricardo Sanchez, the former top Army official in Iraq; Gen. Geoffrey Miller, the former commander of Guantanamo; senior Iraq commander, Major General Walter Wojdakowski; and Col. Thomas Pappas, the one-time head of military intelligence at Abu Ghraib.
Time.
10.11.06.

Iraq: One Year On, Still No Justice For Torture Victims
10.11.06. Amnesty Int. Amnesty International is calling on the Iraqi government to publish the findings of its investigation in the so-called al-Jadiriya case in November 2005, involving the detention and torture of suspects under the control of the Iraqi Interior Ministry.

The URL to Prison and Torture in Iraq is: Here

Sarah Meyer is a researcher living in Sussex, UK.
You can email her at: sarahmeyer@freedom255.com